Solution Builder - Channel Insider
Empowering the next generation Channel
 

Sponsored Links
  • Cisco Small Business Advantage
  • Register for WES 2010 by February 19 and save $400.
  • up.time Easily Monitors Virtual/Physical/Cloud. Free Trial.
  • Seagate® Barracuda® drives fit every desktop need.
  • MSP Partners helps solution providers stay competitive.
  • Learn more about EnterpriseDB @ the Postgres Center
  • Earn 40-50% margins. Zenith open houses show how.
  • CDW Healthcare offers the IT solutions you need.
  • One number. One voicemail. Sprint Mobile Integration.
  • FREE Sophos Encryption Tool: Encrypt, compress and share files easily.
  • Give your customers more with LSI 6Gb/s solutions.






  • Channel Insider conferred 75 awards to vendor, distribution, solution provider and industry groups for performance excellence. Check out all the winners in the 28 Bull’s Eye Award categories.
    >> Bull’s Eye Central


     

    Keeping Out of the Patent Briarpatch

    in Solution Builder


    Article Rating:starstarstarstarstar / 0
    Article Views: 1183

    Rate This Article:
    Add This Article To:
    Code writers beware. Lawsuits make it chancy even when you're writing code for internal systems.

    While in the shower one day, Ole Tange came up with a great idea. He was going to launch a video store in his native Denmark. Only this store was on the Internet; customers would rent and watch videos online.

    He put together a rough prototype of his site and showed it to a friend. Sure, it was slick. Sure, it was cool.

    But it was also quite likely to get him in trouble. His friend pointed out a few elements that were covered by software patents, which he would have to pay royalties for—even though they were based on "open" standards. In fact, "most of the functionality of the shop was patented," Tange says.

    The MPEG-4 format for streaming video falls under 40 different U.S. and European patents, for instance. One of those patent-holders, Acacia Research Corp. of Newport Beach, Calif., is seeking royalties that can cost a video site such as Tange's as much as 2% of its gross sales.

    Resource Library:

    Tange abandoned his concept. Now, he and colleague Carsten Svaneborg spend their free time fighting software patent legislation in the European Community through their grassroots Web site, softwarepatenter.dk.

    But innovative sites like what Tange hoped to launch aren't the only digital products caught in the crossfire. Corporations writing their own code have to be careful, too. "Most software products probably infringe on multiple patents," says Svaneborg. The Federal Trade Commission described the situation in an October report as a "patent thicket that a company must hack its way through."

    Intellectual-property rights are the soft underbelly of corporate information systems. Few companies pursue patents for homegrown software. And few companies worry whether that homegrown software infringes on any patents, either.

    "In all of my 18-plus years of my career, I have yet to see a company that has a formal process around protecting their software intellectual property," says Andy Miller, vice president of technical architecture at the Broomfield, Colo., office-supply distributor Corporate Express. "Companies that don't have an R&D organization don't tend to look at things as being patentable or not."

    And they certainly don't do a patent search before writing internal code. "Unless the patent holder can find out about [infringing code], there's nothing much that they can do," says Miller.

    But Internet applications are different. Web sites and Internet services have to stand up under public scrutiny because their functions are out in plain view of any sophisticated programmer—or patent attorney.

    As the Grateful Dead once sang, "It's even worse than it appears." Patents on "electronic shopping carts" and other Web site features can sneak up and bite e-commerce companies. Even improving "open source" software can haunt you. Depending on the licensing scheme, you may have to hand over the copyright to any changes you make to source code.

    Corporate Express has tightly controlled any work it does that modifies supposedly "open" code—to prevent its development work from crossing the line into charity.

    For example, the company has standardized on JBoss, an open-source Java application server. As a policy, Miller says he keeps developers from customizing JBoss' code unless there's a specific problem for which there's no workaround. When needed, Miller allows those patches and them with the JBoss community. But he requires any work on an open source project to be pre-approved by him.

    "We don't just endorse people working on open source projects willy-nilly," Miller says.

    Some times, a corporation can get some litigation cover by only using code from a "safe" vendor. Sun Microsystems and Hewlett-Packard, for instance, are indemnifying their customers who use Linux against a possible SCO Group suit, because of rights they already hold.

    Still, with the atmosphere surrounding the software industry being what it is, there's only one way to be sure your homegrown code is safe. Keep your lawyer handy.





    Discuss Keeping Out of the Patent Briarpatch
     
    >>> Be the FIRST to comment on this article!
     

     
     
    >>> More Solution Builder Articles          >>> More By Sean Gallagher
     


     


    [ci] feeds
    XML
    Add Channel News, Product Reviews, Trends and Analysis to your RSS newsreader or My Yahoo!


    HTML PLAIN TEXT

    Keep on top of news for VARs and Resellers with CI's Weekly Newsletter and Alerts.

     


    CHANNEL RESOURCE CENTER
     
     
    How much time do you spend hunting for enterprise IT content?
    Let Enterprise TechBrief do the work for you. Aggregated content, tech news, product reviews, vendor updates, how-to’s—all you need to boost your efficiencies and cut costs, all from one place.
    enterprisetechbrief.com
     
    Should You Be Using “up.time”?
    Easily Monitor Virtual, Physical, and Cloud based assets, applications and services from a unified Dashboard with up.time. Deep Monitoring across platforms and along with best-of-breed reporting. Over 700 enterprise customers in 32 countries.
    Free Trial Download Here (Virtual Appliance available)
    Managed service providers are using regulatory compliance and industry standards to win business and give customers peace of mind. Join host Larry Walsh of Ziff Davis Enterprise and his guests on Friday, February 19, 2010, at 1:00 pm ET for a discussion of “Compliance as a Service.”
    Register Today