Channel News and Analysis - Channel Insider
Empowering the next generation Channel
 

Sponsored Links
  • Cisco Small Business Advantage
  • Register for WES 2010 by February 19 and save $400.
  • up.time Easily Monitors Virtual/Physical/Cloud. Free Trial.
  • Seagate® Barracuda® drives fit every desktop need.
  • MSP Partners helps solution providers stay competitive.
  • Learn more about EnterpriseDB @ the Postgres Center
  • Earn 40-50% margins. Zenith open houses show how.
  • CDW Healthcare offers the IT solutions you need.
  • One number. One voicemail. Sprint Mobile Integration.
  • FREE Sophos Encryption Tool: Encrypt, compress and share files easily.
  • Give your customers more with LSI 6Gb/s solutions.






  • Channel Insider conferred 75 awards to vendor, distribution, solution provider and industry groups for performance excellence. Check out all the winners in the 28 Bull’s Eye Award categories.
    >> Bull’s Eye Central


     

    Resellers, Consumers File Suit Against Apple

    in Channel News and Analysis


    Article Rating:starstarstarstarstar / 0
    Article Views: 1114

    Rate This Article:
    Add This Article To:
    A class action lawsuit accuses Apple of holding back product, stealing customer information, and other actions that hurt the channel.

    A group of Apple resellers in conjunction with consumers have filed a 26-page class action lawsuit against the company accusing it of unlawful business practices, breach of contract, misappropriation of trade secrets and other practices illegal under consumer law.

    The suit was filed in San Francisco Superior Court last Thursday by two former Apple resellers, one of whom, Joe Weingarten, is the head of the Apple Resellers Association, which represents some 70 resellers across the United States. Also taking part in the action are three named Mac users.

    According to an interview with Weingarten on the The Mac Observer, a Mac Web site, part of the reason for the suit is Apple's deteriorating relationship with some of its dealers. "Apple is pushing dealers to the point of where they're going out of business because of their actions," Weingarten claimed.

    One of the accusations made against Apple is that it unfairly held back product from the channel while stocking the shelves of its own Apple stores.

    Resource Library:
    The company is also accused of using discriminatory pricing to undercut dealers, selling products below cost in order to get customers away from independent stores.

    Another key claim is that Apple stole customer information from dealers, approaching these customers in order to sell direct to them.

    In addition to the dealer-related charges, the company is also accused in the suit of reselling refurbished equipment to dealers as new, selling product to nonqualified education and government customers at a discount, and lying to consumers in an attempt to cover up its own culpability.

    Click here to read Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols' opinion on Apple's reseller conflicts.

    The case is part of a string of complaints from dealers over their relationship with Apple. Last week, two independent dealers in California shut their doors, blaming Apple directly for the closures.

    Tom Santos, president of MacAdam, claimed its closure was due to "consistently bad behaviour of our number one supplier, Apple Computer. They have made it so difficult to get product in a timely fashion and treat our customers with the respect that they treat their Apple direct customers."

    Santos had previously made headlines in 2004, when he filed a suit against Apple alleging the company had been engaged in unfair competition, breach of contract and fraud. A case management conference concerning the suit is due to take place in June this year.

    The second Apple dealer to close its doors, MacOnline, made its feelings known through a statement taped to the closed doors of its offices. Headed "WE QUIT!", the statement claimed, "Apple fills their retail stores first with new products fulfilling demand, then supplying resellers with only a few units, weeks and sometimes months later."

    Apple is also being sued by a French consumer organization over its use of DRM in music downloads. Click here to read more.

    While not commenting on the cases against it, Apple has consistently claimed that its intention with its retail stores program is to expand the market, rather than to put the squeeze on its existing channel.

    However, the company also has a long-term strategy of setting higher goals for dealers to achieve Specialist status, which is required in order to gain certain discounts on products and equipment. Since the end of 2003, specialists have been required to meet attach-rate targets for many products, for example, by ensuring that 60% of Macs sold have an extended warranty attached to them. The company has also beefed up its direct sales team for large accounts, particularly in the creative and government sectors.



    Discuss Resellers, Consumers File Suit Against Apple
     
    >>> Be the FIRST to comment on this article!
     

     
     
    >>> More Channel News and Analysis Articles          >>> More By Ian Betteridge
     


     


    [ci] feeds
    XML
    Add Channel News, Product Reviews, Trends and Analysis to your RSS newsreader or My Yahoo!


    HTML PLAIN TEXT

    Keep on top of news for VARs and Resellers with CI's Weekly Newsletter and Alerts.

     


    CHANNEL RESOURCE CENTER
     
     
    How much time do you spend hunting for enterprise IT content?
    Let Enterprise TechBrief do the work for you. Aggregated content, tech news, product reviews, vendor updates, how-to’s—all you need to boost your efficiencies and cut costs, all from one place.
    enterprisetechbrief.com
     
    Should You Be Using “up.time”?
    Easily Monitor Virtual, Physical, and Cloud based assets, applications and services from a unified Dashboard with up.time. Deep Monitoring across platforms and along with best-of-breed reporting. Over 700 enterprise customers in 32 countries.
    Free Trial Download Here (Virtual Appliance available)
    Managed service providers are using regulatory compliance and industry standards to win business and give customers peace of mind. Join host Larry Walsh of Ziff Davis Enterprise and his guests on Friday, February 19, 2010, at 1:00 pm ET for a discussion of “Compliance as a Service.”
    Register Today