Commentary - Channel Insider
Empowering the next generation Channel
 

Bull’s Eye Awards
Nominations Open for Channel Insider 2009 Bull’s Eye Awards
Nominations are now open for the Channel Insider 2009 Bull’s Eye Awards, which recognize excellence in customer service, technology prowess, business acumen, channel leadership, communications and community building, and innovation among vendors, solution providers, distributors and channel services companies.



Sponsored Links
  • Control VM Sprawl, What You Don’t Know Can Hurt You
  • FREE Sophos Encryption Tool: Encrypt, compress and share files easily
  • LSI 6Gb/s Portfolio Expands to Include SATA+SAS HBAs
  • Reduce the cost of managing your mobile workers.
  • Find out 7 Ways to Drive Data Center Efficiency
  • SonicWALL breaks through network and email gridlock
  • Save up to 40% on calling costs with Avaya Aura™



  •  

    Ode to Broken Windows

    in Commentary


    Article Rating:starstarstarstarstar / 106
    Article Views: 20507

    Rate This Article:
    Add This Article To:
    Despite Microsoft’s repeated efforts, Vista is a failed experiment. Worse for the boys in Redmond, Vista may mark the turning point when Microsoft lost the operating system as the foundation of its business.

    Let it be said that Windows Vista didn’t fail for a lack of trying.

    Microsoft had declared the drop-dead end-of-life date for new installations of Window XP—the last generation of the operating system—would come Jan. 31, 2009. Now, under pressure from business consumers and system builders, it’s extending XP’s life once again. System builders can place orders for XP through distributors for deliveries as late as May 2009.

    Extending the deadline is good news for PC solution providers and system builders, who have labored to deliver machines to customers loaded with Vista only to have them rejected out of hand. Microsoft’s decision may also signal the final act of contrition for the beleaguered operating system that, despite Microsoft’s repeated efforts, has failed to capture the imagination of business-technology consumers.

    Microsoft will claim more than 300 million installations of Vista since its release, but most of those are consumer PCs sold through retailers and direct distributors. According to a recent survey by ITIC and Sunbelt Software of more than 700 senior corporate executives, only 10 percent had deployed Vista on their desktops, whereas 88 percent reported Windows XP as their primary client OS.

     

     MORE ON MICROSOFT WINDOWS


    Does Microsoft have a Chance with Windows 7?

    Resource Library:

    Vista's Prematurely Reported Death 

    Ode to Broken Windows (Vista) 

    Vista Views: What Users Say About the Windows Operating System 

    Microsoft, Apple, Google Sued for Patent Infrigement 
      

    Some analysts and industry observers say the latest reprieve will put more pressure on Microsoft to expedite the release of Windows 7, the next-generation operating system that’s based on the Vista framework but with a significantly smaller memory footprint. The reality, we may find, is that Vista is the last meaningful client-side Windows release. Here’s why.

    More than five years in the making, Vista was heralded in 2006 by Microsoft as the most comprehensive rollout of an operating system in history. It promised the revolution of functionality, reliability and security users desired in an operating system without the fanfare that announced the birth of Windows 95 more than a decade earlier.

    While Microsoft lauded its creation, many said features such as the multiscreen desktop and improved, integrated search were innovations long available in Apple’s operating system. Worse, the high-resolution graphics capabilities meant a lesser user experience on older machines. And, of course, users quickly discovered that the minimum 1GB RAM requirement was hardly enough to operate the bloated OS.

    Two years on, Vista is nothing short of an incompressible failure. According to Net Applications, Microsoft’s iron grip on the desktop showed signs of weakness in 2008 as Windows market share slipped below 90 percent market share for the first time in more than a decade. More worrisome is Apple’s OS X—the preferred operating system for the Mac—increased to nearly 9 percent, unprecedented considering that it wasn’t that long ago that Apple needed a cash infusion from Microsoft to stay alive.

    In preparation for Vista’s release, Microsoft conducted what it described as one of the most comprehensive beta testing periods ever. It released advanced copies of Vista to partners and independent software vendors to develop application drivers and test interoperability. Several Microsoft executives stated in the lead-up to Vista’s release that the operating system’s release would have the concurrent availability of thousands of applications, making it ready and usable out of the gate. Some speculated that Microsoft was actually trying to short-circuit the traditional 18-month adoption curve of any new operating system.

    Reality check, nearly two years have passed and business users continue to avoid Vista like the plague. One report even stated that despite Microsoft’s client division increasing revenues by 14 percent in 2008, much of that gain came from corporate clients that paid for access to Vista but chose not to deploy it. No wonder solution providers, system builders and distributors hailed XP’s latest extension.

    At last summer’s Microsoft Worldwide Partner Conference, a string of Microsoft executives took the stage with fiery speeches about how they would take the fight to competitors and show the world the benefits of Vista. They launched the miserable Jerry Seinfeld advertising campaign, which flamed out after just one dreadful spot. The company launched a new Web site to test applications for capability with Vista. And it released a series of reports and case studies that boasted Vista’s benefits. For the most part, these efforts have done little to reverse Vista’s over-the-cliff course.

    Some may look to Windows 7 as the saving grace, but even it comes in late 2009—as some now project—it may be too little, too late. Even Microsoft has recognized that computing is moving to the cloud, and Bill Gates’ heir Ray Ozzie is making it his mission to move Microsoft into the cloud. Too bad that—like most efforts in Microsoft’s history—it comes after rivals are already at the destination. IBM announced that it’s pressing forward with plans for Linux-based thin clients. Wyse Technology is finding traction with its thin-client technologies. Netbooks and smartphones are rapidly becoming clients of choice for many mobile users. And Google’s Chrome browser is a thinly veiled beta of a cloud-based operating system.

    Microsoft is sure to keep pressing its case for Vista until the bitter end. But no number of Mojave ads is going to save Vista from its inevitable end of going down as the Edsel and New Coke of the computing world. In the end, it may also mark the turning point when Microsoft lost the operating system as the cornerstone of its business.

    Lawrence M. Walsh is vice president and group publisher of Channel Insider.

     






    Discuss Ode to Broken Windows
     
    Microsoft is the past. Google is the present. The future? Something that brews in...
    With the intro of Vista I had reached my toleration for MS operating systems, the...
    Coca Cola was pretty quick to recognize the error and put New Coke to bed. ...
    I just received my new Dell laptop recently. It's the beefiest machine that I've...
    Comment threads like the ones before mine have been 10 to 1 or greater in user...
    It is too bad Microsoft had to strong arm system builders with Vista. I kinda wish...
    What a load of crap - a lie told often enough takes on the appearance of...
    What a disaster. For me, I just cannot get over Vista's hardware requirements. I...
    Yes, Vista is bad code. XP, not much better. Way back :Windows for Workgroups 3.11...
    I have every OS installed and Vista is by far better than any Linux version and just...
    I will Mirror what most of the other writers are saying, being critical of Vista,...
    I don't think Microsoft's mistake is that bad! While I agree Vista stinks, I don't...
    I agree with you completely. My stomach turns now when some idiot who doesn't know...
    It's not a failure, it's doing just what microsoft knew it would. they can't charge...
    OK - Google employee! Dork!
    Bigger Dork! What, you been in IT for 2 years???
    Jettison away Nerd!
    No one cares what you have to say because you don't even know what your talking...
    OK - Here's another nerd!
    TRU DAT! Know one here knows what they are talking about, especially the eWeek...
    Well, If you've been in IT for 20 years, then your allowed to be a nerd and move. ...
    NO! Vista is not bad code. You have no clue what you are talking about! You...
    Ed, someone with some sense. You should apply to take the VP's job here at eWeek. ...
    I can respect your comments - I won't call you a dork. However, one correction. ...
    NICE - conspiracy theorists now! DORK!
    I have read all of these comments and am a bit puzzled. My newest computer - custom...
    Hey Anonymous Loozah... do YOU have anything interesting or intelligent to say or...
    Folks: Broken, Broken?? try the whole wall gone. What do you expect, take...
    Folks: Why should I fix Vista for M/S. I have worked on several Vista systems....
    You must be a real Dork - I have installed Vista on hundreds of systems and have had...
    4 Processors? Come one, you realy don't understand what you have, now do you?...
    Mac/OS in one virtual machine - thats a neat trick - you obviosly don't know what...
    Techpro is right about the hardware requirements. They're ridiculous and...
    AMEN, Brother!
    I do, but not for the dorks here. And by the way, "Anonymous Loozah" is what this...
    hmmm
    do any of you know what you are talking about??? i have vista and i have no...
    AMEN to their AMENS
    The only thing I don't like about Vista is the fact that if I walk into any shop to...
    If you are a home user you are fine as you won't tax the machine. If you are a...
    Vista may indeed be a failure but I have been running it since beta 1 with little or...
    I am now "involved" with Ms.Ubuntu, Mrs. XP & Lady Vista. Ubuntu is my sweet youth:...
    Vista is a working operating system. It's bugs aren't much different at this point...
    To the arrogant anonymous loosah who thinks everyone else is an idiot: Do you use...
    It is possible to run Mac OS in a virtual machine. Not legal, but possible. Google...
    There were two dreadful Gates/Seinfeld ads, not one.
    If Microsoft really abandons XP, maybe the U.S. government to seize it under eminent...
    Got to agree on this. This isn't Windows Me or Dos 4, which was problem. Those who...
    The Loozah who likes to flame others with the word Dork is obviously a Redmond...
    Hmmm... Oddly, around here we write programs for a living. Our major product is a...
    I am really tired of all this bashing of Vista!!! It is THE best version of the...
    I don't think everyone is an Idiot. There were a few other smart people here. It...
    TRU DAT - Too!!!!
    Another AMEN Brother! Let me say, I am a big Microsoft fan, but I like the other...
    Despite public opinion, New Coke was not a failure. New Coke happened on Coca Cola's...
    We have Windows 2000 Pro and XP and two lousy Vista on our machines. We are getting...
    There is an old saying that "It is better to be thought a fool than to open your...
    And you are clearly a Microsoft Employee....
    Besides the annoying pop up ever time I go to install a piece of software, do you...
    As with almost all MS OS releases, Vista wasn't that good until SP1 was rolled out....
    I feel your pain AL. It must be tough being the only smart person in the whole...
    I just noticed this article lost a star it its rating since I first read it earlier...
    As a business executive, the transition to Vista and Office 2007 is profoundly...
    I figured that if the flaming loser can be anonymous, so can I. Please - if you...
    Memory may be super cheap, as you put it, but the 32 bit limitation on memory...
    As far as I know, Coke has NO patents on their formula. That's how they've kept it...
    Guys -- Vista code is no better than XP's code as far as the end user experience is...
    Just before Christmas I got a nifty neat-o, Dell XPS laptop that came loaded with...
    This is really pointing back to the mistake Microsoft said on minimum requirements. ...
    In my opinion, Vista is awesome. I have it on my laptop computer, and it works very...
    The only place Google leads is search. What does Google have to do with operating...
    MS definitely missed with Vista. I'll agree to that but its not all that bad. teh 64...
    Way too many of the Anonymous Lozer comments are just insults, with little or no...
    Amen!
    With a downsized IT section and smaller budgets, I don't know how our organization...
    Micro-Soft has had the same problem(s) with their software. They have delibertly...
    Been running Vistah! on two machines here at home since March 2007. Also have an XP...
    Vista is not a turd, but it's not very far above it, either. Biggest complaint is...
    BTW, the Vista machines are great as long as the horsepower is there (i.e. dual core...
    Boycott is not going to happen until, Linux runs better or other OS is created. I...
    Unfortunately for Microsoft XP is good enough for bosses with tight budgets. They'll...
    No matter how much you polish a turd, it's still a turd. I have used Vista since...
    If you were to think and do a little research before you type. You would know that...
    Of course XP would run faster on the same hardware. It does less work. XP is less...
    I cannot imagine what you are saying about Vista being the only choice that you have...
    I was at the PDC and saw Windows 7. I was really not impressed. It is simply an...
    The bottom line when doing an update is whether or not the update makes you more...
    Microsoft should require all of it's employees use Vista on new dual core systems...
    Windows Vista would have had better reception if the third party vendors and...
    I too have been pushed over the Microsoft Edge and jumped on board the Mac Wagon and...
    Ok, very good discussions about Vista. I've been running Vista for over a year and I...
    A year ago I bought a high end notebook dual core, 2 ghz 3 gb RAM, cache, high end...
    Ok, I guess I'll wade into the fray here since like alot of the posters here, I'm...
    Don't blame Vista(MS) for apps that won't run on it, because the vendor/developer...
    Just like all these anonymous readers aren't shoving their opinions down our throats...
    Let me be up front in saying I use Mac for both personal & business (Network Admin)....
    Maybe I drank the Micrsoft kool-aid. Sometimes I feel as if I am the only one to...
    If you dont like UAC just turn it off. What's your point?
    Vista is the most advanced and feature rich OS available today period. Face reality....
    >>> Post your comment now!
     

     
     
    >>> More Commentary Articles          >>> More By Lawrence Walsh
     


     


    [ci] feeds
    XML
    Add Channel News, Product Reviews, Trends and Analysis to your RSS newsreader or My Yahoo!


    HTML PLAIN TEXT

    Keep on top of news for VARs and Resellers with CI's Weekly Newsletter and Alerts.

     


    CHANNEL RESOURCE CENTER
     
     
    Enterprise Mobility Zone
    The Enterprise Mobility Zone (EMZ) blog is a tool designed to help senior IT executives discuss, create and deploy next-generation mobile strategies in their organizations.
    Go beyond yesterday's tactical approach to mobility!
     
    Build A More Efficient Data Center
    Demands are growing but budgets are not. Solve your pressing IT issues using the resources you already have. Determine which technologies can help you drive efficiencies and how they are applied. Gain a quick ROI on new initiatives
    Find out how
    Let Enterprise TechBrief do the work for you. Aggregated content, tech news, product reviews, vendor updates, how-to’s—all you need to boost your efficiencies and cut costs, all from one place.
    enterprisetechbrief.com