Vista Shines as Tablet PlatformBy Anne Chen | Posted 2007-01-30 Email Print
Re-Thinking HR: What Every CIO Needs to Know About Tomorrow's Workforce
Review: eWEEK Labs' tests of the operating system on two Tablet PCs show that Vista smoothes and enhances the tablet computing experience.
Microsoft's decision to incorporate Tablet PC features and functionality into the Windows Vista operating system is one that eWEEK Labs believes will help to convert Tablet PC skeptics.
We installed the operating system on two Tablet PCsLenovo's ThinkPad X60 Tablet and Fujitsu's LifeBook T4215and found that Microsoft has delivered a much more practical and smoother tablet experience in Vista.
ThinkPad X60 Tablet
We've always been fans of Lenovo's ThinkPad notebooks, so it was no surprise that we were pleased by the Vista experience on the ThinkPad X60 Tablet.
Released in late 2006, the ThinkPad X60 Tablet is a convertible notebook with a starting weight of 3.8 pounds. With an eight-cell battery, the ThinkPad X60 Tablet can deliver more than 8 hours of battery life at a slightly increased weight of about 4.16 pounds.
In its basic configuration, the ThinkPad X60 Tablet comes with Intel's 1.67GHz Core Duo L2400 LV processor, 1GB of RAM, a 60GB hard drive, Intel's GMA (Graphics Media Accelerator) 945 and an integrated Intel Wi-Fi module capable of accessing 802.11 a, b and g networks. This configuration is priced at $1,823.
The ThinkPad X60 Tablet we tested had the same configuration except for a slightly larger (80GB) hard drive. Our $1,879 evaluation unit came with Windows XP Tablet PC Edition 2005 installed and had a 12.1-inch TFT XGA display.
Installing Vista on the ThinkPad X60 was almost problem-free. Before installation, we used Microsoft's Windows Vista Upgrade Advisor to determine what issues we might run into during the upgrade process. The Upgrade Advisor, which determined that the Windows Vista Business SKU was best for our hardware configuration, could not see the DVD drive in our docking station for some reason. Since we knew we had a DVD drive, we chose to go ahead with the installation.
The Vista installation took about an hour on the ThinkPad X60 Tablet and required that we uninstall Symantec Antivirus, which came installed directly from Lenovo.
Once Vista was installed, we found that we were missing only a few drivers. We had no problems using the ThinkPad TrackPoint or the digital stylus, which we used for taking notes with the Windows Journal app that comes with Vista.
We did, however, run into issues when it came to using Lenovo's suite of ThinkVantage support tools. We had to download software from the Lenovo Web site and then install it before we could use any Lenovo tools. We also ran into a problem using the biometric fingerprint reader, but we found no Vista driver that could fix it. Lenovo officials said they are working on a fix.
When the ThinkPad X60 Tablet was first announced, we were concerned with Lenovo's decision not to release it with a Core 2 Duo processor and instead go with the ultra low-voltage Core Duo processor. However, Vista ran fine on the unit. In fact, our evaluation system turned in a respectable 3 (out of 5) on the Windows Experience Index score.
The overall Windows Experience Index score is based on the lowest score in each of five categories: processor, memory, graphics, gaming graphics capability and hard drive. The ThinkPad X60 Tablet's graphics adapter and memory came up short on the index, but business users should get more than enough performance when running Vista on the system.
Overall, we found the ThinkPad X60 Tablet to be a good Vista machine. The handwriting recognition is greatly improved, and pen flicks, which allow users to navigate the notebook using a flick of the pen, is an addition Tablet PC users are bound to use extensively.
IT managers considering the ThinkPad X60 Tablet for their user base should consider the multitouch/multiview display if they have outdoor users or those who might benefit from touch screen functionality. Vista's touch screen capabilities are what the ThinkPad X60 Tablet's display is made for. We do, however, recommend the eight-cell battery (an additional $50) for all users.
Next Page: Testing the Fujitsu LifeBook T4215.
With a four-cell battery, we got almost three hours of battery performance from our ThinkPad X60 Tablet evaluation unit. Despite fears about Vista's power-hungry nature, we saw no noticeable battery performance degradation when running Vista on the notebook as opposed to Windows XP Tablet PC.
Fujitsu LifeBook T4215
Fujitsu's LifeBook T4215 is a convertible notebook best suited for those who make heavy use of tablet capabilities but who want access to a traditional laptop.
The base configuration of the LifeBook T4215, which was released late last year, includes Intel's 1.66GHz Core 2 Duo T5500 processor, 512MB of RAM, a 40GB hard drive and an integrated Intel Wi-Fi module capable of accessing 802.11 a, b and g networks. This configuration, which is priced at $1,799, also includes a Modular DVD/CD-RW Combo Drive.
The LifeBook T4215 we tested was armed with the more robust 2GHz Intel T2700 Core 2 Duo Processor, 1GB of RAM and a 100GB hard drive. Our unit was also equipped with an indoor/outdoor display with wide viewing angles and a modular dual-layer, multi-format DVD drive. In this configuration, the LifeBook costs $2,429.
For users who want to run Vista on their LifeBook T4215, we recommend buying at least 1GB of SDRAM.
Like the Lenovo X60 Tablet, our LifeBook T4215 evaluation unit shipped with Windows XP Tablet PC Edition 2005. Microsoft's Windows Vista Upgrade Advisor, which we ran before installing Vista, determined that Vista Business was best suited for our hardware configuration. The Advisor warned us to uninstall Norton AntiVirus and the Toshiba Bluetooth Stack before proceeding with the Vista upgrade.
Installation of Vista took about an hour. Upon booting Vista for the first time, we scanned our LifeBook T4215 to determine its score on the Windows Experience Index. Our configuration got a score of 2.3 out of 5, hindered by the LifeBook T4215'graphics performance when running Windows Aero. When it came to processing performance, though, the system got extremely high marks.
Despite the lower graphics score, we found that the LifeBook T4215 handled Aero just fine. As with the Lenovo ThinkPad X60 Tablet, Vista dramatically improved the handwriting experience on the LifeBook. Handwriting recognition was faster and more accurate than it was pre-Vista, and the device's full-featured TIP (Tablet Input Panel) made input easy.
However, the first time we ran Vista, the calibration of the LifeBook's pen was off by more than an inch. Rebooting fixed that issue, but we found the LifeBook T4215's pen and screen to be less responsive than the Lenovo ThinkPad T60 Tablet's. For example, when it came to pen flicks, we were never able to move the pen just right; the ThinkPad was much more forgiving.
We also ran into some issues when using the fingerprint reader on the LifeBook T4215 running Vista. Other than that, however, there were no driver issues that couldn't be easily remedied downloading fixes off the Fujitsu Web site.
Senior Writer Anne Chen can be reached at email@example.com.
Check out eWEEK.com's for Microsoft and Windows news, views and analysis.