Office Alternatives Explore Server-Based AppsBy Michael Myser | Print
Re-Imagining Linux Platforms to Meet the Needs of Cloud Service Providers
Sun Microsystems, with its StarOffice suite, and the open-source OpenOffice.org consider server-based applications as a way to boost security, portability and deployment.While Microsoft quietly pursues developing new servers for its Microsoft Office applications, Sun Microsystems' StarOffice and the open-source OpenOffice.org are taking another route with their applications. Citing security, portability and deployment benefits, both see offering server-based applications as a future option.
In fact, Sun took it so seriously that it went down this path several years ago.
"We talked about a server version of office in 2000 and 2001, and demonstrated [it] at JavaOne 2001," said Manish Punjabi, group marketing manager for the user software group at Sun Microsystems Inc. "Three years ago, one could argue the timing was off because the economy was relatively low and the market wasn't ready to absorb it."
Sun says server-based applications offer several benefits over desktop applications. Rather than installing software on every desktop in an organization, the applications are deployed at the server level. On the security side, viruses often come into an organization via Office attachments, and having them reside on a server makes it potentially easier to monitor. Server-based files and applications are arguably more accessible via the Internet than desktop-based apps, as well.
But that doesn't mean Microsoft will pursue it. Instead, the company will likely offer additional Office Server products on which to more efficiently run desktop-based Office applications and more collaboration features. This allows Microsoft to encourage upgrades to the entire "office system" as a revenue generator.
"A scenario that I don't see happening in the near-term is running Excel [directly] off of a server," said Paul DeGoot, an analyst at Directions on Microsoft, based in Kirkland, Wash. "I think there's a lot of merit to Sun's argument about server-based applications, but that is not popular for Microsoft."
"Microsoft makes too much money from Office for it to even consider putting it on the server," he said. "They've been reasonably successful at fighting this off previously, and there's not a lot of reason for Microsoft to say they need to change models."
OpenOffice.org community manager Louis Suarez-Potts sees Microsoft's expansion of its servers as yet another way to get enterprises locked into one system, leaving them vulnerable to viruses and "innovation gaps."
"For Microsoft, the only way they seemingly innovate is excluding everything that's happening outside," Suarez-Potts said.
OpenOffice.org, which on Wednesday celebrated its fourth year in existence (Sun donated the StarOffice source code to the open-source community on Oct. 13, 2000) has also seen its own server-based applications previously. For example, the Linux Terminal Service Project (LTSP.org) demonstrated OpenOffice.org applications running in a thin-client arrangement.
"It runs amazingly well," Suarez-Potts said. "It's very impressive technology."
Future versions of OpenOffice.org will be lighter and increasingly modular, which could allow not only more flexibility, but also the ability to more easily offer server-based options of the applications.
"The trend in computing is toward relying less on the physical materiality of desktop computers and more on the ethereal effects of the Web," Suarez-Potts said. Thin clients and server-based applications lend themselves to this idea and could be a viable part of OpenOffice.org's future.