Channel News and Analysis - Channel Insider
Empowering the next generation Channel
 

Bull’s Eye Awards
Nominations Open for Channel Insider 2009 Bull’s Eye Awards
Nominations are now open for the Channel Insider 2009 Bull’s Eye Awards, which recognize excellence in customer service, technology prowess, business acumen, channel leadership, communications and community building, and innovation among vendors, solution providers, distributors and channel services companies.



Sponsored Links
  • Control VM Sprawl, What You Don’t Know Can Hurt You
  • FREE Sophos Encryption Tool: Encrypt, compress and share files easily
  • LSI 6Gb/s Portfolio Expands to Include SATA+SAS HBAs
  • Reduce the cost of managing your mobile workers.
  • Find out 7 Ways to Drive Data Center Efficiency
  • SonicWALL breaks through network and email gridlock
  • Save up to 40% on calling costs with Avaya Aura™



  •  

    Microsoft Tries to Explain Away Outlook 2007 Controversy

    in Channel News and Analysis


    Article Rating:starstarstarstarstar / 0
    Article Views: 820

    Rate This Article:
    Add This Article To:
    Microsoft explains its controversial decision to unify the rendering and editing engines in Outlook 2007 and use only the Word 2007 engine, even though there are some HTML and CSS attributes that it does not support.

    Microsoft is trying to dampen criticism by explaining its controversial decision to unify the rendering and editing engines in Outlook 2007 and use only the Word 2007 engine, even though there are some HTML and Cascading Style Sheet attributes that the engine does not currently support.

    The move is a significant change from previous versions of Outlook, which actually used two rendering engines: Internet Explorer's engine was used for reading content, while Word was used for editing content when a user was composing messages.

    Outlook 2007 now uses the HTML parsing and rendering engine from Word 2007 to display HTML message bodies.

    What is the outlook for Office collaboration? Find out here.

    However, there are some HTML and CSS attributes that the Word 2007 rendering engine does not support, and Outlook 2007 now does not use the same standards as Internet Explorer 7.

    The move has not been well-received by some bloggers, such as SitePoint's Kevin Yank, who said in a recent post that instead of taking advantage of Internet Explorer 7, Outlook 2007 uses the very limited support for HTML and CSS built into Word 2007 to display HTML e-mail messages.

    Resource Library:
    "This new rendering engine isn't any better than that which Outlook previously used—indeed, it's far worse," Yank wrote. "With this release, Outlook drops from being one of the best clients for HTML e-mail support to the level of Lotus Notes and Eudora, which, in the words of Campaign Monitor's David Grenier, 'are serial killers making our e-mail design lives hell.'"

    Yank also noted that unless a user's HTML e-mails are "very, very simple, you're going to run into problems with Outlook 2007, and in most cases the only solution to those problems will be to reduce the complexity of your HTML e-mail design to accommodate Outlook's limited feature set."

    Microsoft Word recently came of age. Click here to read more.

    Asked about the controversial move, Chris Capossela, who manages the Microsoft Office System family of products, admitted that "in Office 2007, by default, when you write or read an e-mail in Outlook, we are using Word as the underlying engine for that."

    The reason: Microsoft has done a lot of work to make Word the "best authoring and reading environment possible. So, when you are writing an e-mail, it's nice to get the spell-check capabilities of Word, or the ribbon capabilities of Word, right in that e-mail authoring and reading experience," he told eWEEK.

    Microsoft has just released an document titled "Information on the Changes in Outlook Using Word as the Email Editor" to further explain its rationale for the move.

    The document notes that, in the past, when people replied or forwarded HTML e-mails, previous versions of Outlook would first use Internet Explorer's rendering engine to view it, then would have to switch over to Word, the compose engine, when replying.

    eWEEK Labs believes Office 2007 breaks new ground. Read why.

    "This wasn't an ideal experience for customers, as often the content people created looked different to the recipient receiving it—like the formatting would be slightly off, or things wouldn't appear as they had when the message was in 'compose' mode," it said.

    "Added to that, one of the big things we heard in designing Outlook 2007 was that our customers wanted the rich editing tools they were used to from Word. Internet Explorer was not designed to be an editing tool for text, so using this tool was not the best experience for users," the document said.

    The Word team made improvements in how Word 2007 handles HTML content, based on HTML and CSS standards and customer feedback, so the Outlook and Word teams made the decision to unify the rendering and editing engine in Outlook by using Word's engine and "give users a superior editing experience by using Word," the Microsoft document said.

    However, while Microsoft acknowledges in the document that there are some HTML and CSS attributes that are not currently supported by Word's rendering engine, it says "the capabilities that our customers most wanted for their HTML newsletters are supported by Outlook 2007."

    Next Page: "Something screwy going on."

    But SitePoint's Yank disputes this, saying that he tested the two public beta versions of Outlook 2007 and "knew there was something screwy going on. Many of the newsletters I subscribed to had become unreadable, and SitePoint's own publications were looking decidedly unhealthy."

    The solution? Use Microsoft's Outlook 2007 HTML and CSS validator tool, "to tell you which parts of your lean, mean HTML e-mails need to be replaced with old-fashioned HTML sludge. As a second step, you may want to consider giving your Outlook-based readers an easy way to switch to text-only e-mail. Bring on PDF e-mail. I'm ready," he said.

    For Microsoft's part, the company has provided a list of HTML and CSS standards that are—and are not—supported.

    As to why Outlook 2007 does not use the same standards as Internet Explorer 7, Microsoft said, "Customers using Outlook don't just want to display HTML content the way they do in their browser, but [they] also have an expectation that they should be able to author that content as well."

    Read here about the release of Internet Explorer 7 for Windows XP.

    Microsoft's document goes on to say that "a big thing we heard from customers is that they wanted the richness of the editing experience they were used to from Word integrated throughout Outlook. While Internet Explorer 7 is great, it was never intended to be an editing tool."

    Does Microsoft plan to add support for the missing HTML and CSS standards to Word's engine? The company's response was vague: "The Word team is continually examining HTML and CSS support based on customer feedback."

    Check out eWEEK.com's for Microsoft and Windows news, views and analysis.



    Discuss Microsoft Tries to Explain Away Outlook 2007 Controversy
     
    >>> Be the FIRST to comment on this article!
     

     
     
    >>> More Channel News and Analysis Articles          >>> More By Peter Galli
     


     


    [ci] feeds
    XML
    Add Channel News, Product Reviews, Trends and Analysis to your RSS newsreader or My Yahoo!


    HTML PLAIN TEXT

    Keep on top of news for VARs and Resellers with CI's Weekly Newsletter and Alerts.

     


    CHANNEL RESOURCE CENTER
     
     
    Enterprise Mobility Zone
    The Enterprise Mobility Zone (EMZ) blog is a tool designed to help senior IT executives discuss, create and deploy next-generation mobile strategies in their organizations.
    Go beyond yesterday's tactical approach to mobility!
     
    Build A More Efficient Data Center
    Demands are growing but budgets are not. Solve your pressing IT issues using the resources you already have. Determine which technologies can help you drive efficiencies and how they are applied. Gain a quick ROI on new initiatives
    Find out how
    Let Enterprise TechBrief do the work for you. Aggregated content, tech news, product reviews, vendor updates, how-to’s—all you need to boost your efficiencies and cut costs, all from one place.
    enterprisetechbrief.com